Dear Cousin S,
I haven't talked to you in a long time. I was pleased when you accepted my friend request on Facebook, even more so when you asked for news and offered me your work number so I could call you. I wanted to call you. As you know, I didn't. There are a few reasons for this. Most of them have to do with family politics, and how for me, reaching out to one family member can cause unpleasant repercussions from another. But that's a topic for another letter. What I want to explain now is the other reason, the one that has to do with you alone.
You remember, of course, how close we were from the time we were tiny. Visiting with your family, for me, was a wonderful event for the sole reason that I would get to spend time with you. It was never enough time, either. We had a lot of fun together. You have always been my favourite cousin, and I liked you as much as I liked my closest friends.
So why on Earth would I let myself fall out of touch with you? Intimacy is based on sharing. And one day I shared something with you that you couldn't handle.
I was in love. Serious love - I was engaged to be married. And I showed you a picture of the person I wanted to spend the rest of my life with. The woman I wanted to spend the rest of my life with. Not my first girlfriend. I hadn't let my family know about my previous relationships with women. But the seriousness of this relationship meant that I would not be able to keep it secret any more. And I told you, personally, because it was important and I wanted to share.
You didn't speak for a long time. And then you said you had to ask a question. I feared that question. I knew you so well that I knew what that question would be, and I silently begged you not to ask it. But you did. You asked "does this mean that you're attracted to me?" And it was my turn to be silent, because something had died inside me.
You didn't need to ask that question. We grew up together. We played and occasionally argued like sisters. We were certainly family, with all that entails. And so the answer I gave you, when I could speak, heavy-hearted and cold with disappointment, was "you're my cousin." It meant "no". "No" to your question, "no" to your statement that you had to ask it, "no" to your assumption that it was a reasonable thing to ask. And I also wanted to remind you who I was.
Because when you asked your question, you seemed to forget that I was your cousin, the one you'd known all your life. Instead, I became a lesbian. One of them. And you seemed to think that sexual attraction might not work in a normal way for me, that I might not discriminate in my attractions, might not even be subject to the incest taboo. I told you I was in love with and committed to one woman, and you took my revelation and bound it to some vile stereotypes I hadn't wanted to know you held. Your question took our whole previous experience with each other and shut me out of it. You made me into an other. And it hurt.
You didn't leave it like that. You met my partner, you were friendly to her. You were warm to me. You would still like contact. But you never talked about your question, or some other remarks you made later that also made me feel like an outsider, separated from you by your lack of understanding. And your words still echo in my ears. What else would you not understand? What else about me is foreign to you? What fear or distaste will you hold against me, deep in your heart?
So I didn't call you. Because when I thought about calling, I thought about topics of conversation, about words. I would like to believe that I would hear no more words from you that wwould chill my heart. But I can't be sure. So I don't call, and the words do not get said. Your question made me separate from you, and now I find I am stuck in that separation. I want to find my way back. But the destination may no longer exist.
Your loving cousin, as I always have been,
Me
I haven't talked to you in a long time. I was pleased when you accepted my friend request on Facebook, even more so when you asked for news and offered me your work number so I could call you. I wanted to call you. As you know, I didn't. There are a few reasons for this. Most of them have to do with family politics, and how for me, reaching out to one family member can cause unpleasant repercussions from another. But that's a topic for another letter. What I want to explain now is the other reason, the one that has to do with you alone.
You remember, of course, how close we were from the time we were tiny. Visiting with your family, for me, was a wonderful event for the sole reason that I would get to spend time with you. It was never enough time, either. We had a lot of fun together. You have always been my favourite cousin, and I liked you as much as I liked my closest friends.
So why on Earth would I let myself fall out of touch with you? Intimacy is based on sharing. And one day I shared something with you that you couldn't handle.
I was in love. Serious love - I was engaged to be married. And I showed you a picture of the person I wanted to spend the rest of my life with. The woman I wanted to spend the rest of my life with. Not my first girlfriend. I hadn't let my family know about my previous relationships with women. But the seriousness of this relationship meant that I would not be able to keep it secret any more. And I told you, personally, because it was important and I wanted to share.
You didn't speak for a long time. And then you said you had to ask a question. I feared that question. I knew you so well that I knew what that question would be, and I silently begged you not to ask it. But you did. You asked "does this mean that you're attracted to me?" And it was my turn to be silent, because something had died inside me.
You didn't need to ask that question. We grew up together. We played and occasionally argued like sisters. We were certainly family, with all that entails. And so the answer I gave you, when I could speak, heavy-hearted and cold with disappointment, was "you're my cousin." It meant "no". "No" to your question, "no" to your statement that you had to ask it, "no" to your assumption that it was a reasonable thing to ask. And I also wanted to remind you who I was.
Because when you asked your question, you seemed to forget that I was your cousin, the one you'd known all your life. Instead, I became a lesbian. One of them. And you seemed to think that sexual attraction might not work in a normal way for me, that I might not discriminate in my attractions, might not even be subject to the incest taboo. I told you I was in love with and committed to one woman, and you took my revelation and bound it to some vile stereotypes I hadn't wanted to know you held. Your question took our whole previous experience with each other and shut me out of it. You made me into an other. And it hurt.
You didn't leave it like that. You met my partner, you were friendly to her. You were warm to me. You would still like contact. But you never talked about your question, or some other remarks you made later that also made me feel like an outsider, separated from you by your lack of understanding. And your words still echo in my ears. What else would you not understand? What else about me is foreign to you? What fear or distaste will you hold against me, deep in your heart?
So I didn't call you. Because when I thought about calling, I thought about topics of conversation, about words. I would like to believe that I would hear no more words from you that wwould chill my heart. But I can't be sure. So I don't call, and the words do not get said. Your question made me separate from you, and now I find I am stuck in that separation. I want to find my way back. But the destination may no longer exist.
Your loving cousin, as I always have been,
Me
